Why did judas betray jesus reddit. Judas corrupted himself.

Why did judas betray jesus reddit Jesus also specifically forgave the soldiers because they didn’t know what they were doing. Judas was one of a tiny number of people to ever directly know Jesus Christ in the flesh and despite this he did those things. Jesus knew Judas would betray him, but Jesus did not force his hand. " 18. Judas was hoping to see Jesus fulfill the vengeful God role that had been so common in the First Testament, so a paltry 30 pieces of silver was too Sep 13, 2024 · Posted in r/Catholicism by u/Optimal_Cap_4538 • 1,196 points and 438 comments Q: Why did Judas turn against Jesus and promise to betray Him? After all, he had been one of Jesus' 12 disciples, and he had heard His teaching and seen His miracles. Okay, for your real question, given that Jesus knew from the beginning that Judas would betray him, it seems he called him in order to fulfill that role. God would never force someone to do something against their will. He thought if he was threatened with death Jesus would (for lack of a better term) "unleash his divine power" and overthrow the Romans. Scripture tells us there are vessels that are made for destruction. 2-5: "Now Judas, who betrayed him, also knew the place, because Jesus often met there with his disciples. it doesn't appear to mean "from eternity past" but more likely "from the beginning of His discipleship". AskReddit, Ouija-style. There's no reason He couldn't have gone to Jerusalem and been arrested there. We should marvel at the love Jesus shows to Judas, as he will show the same love to us lowly sinners. Jesus had given Judas power and authority to cast out demons and heal the sick during His ministry just like the rest of the twelve - and also the money bag which conferred on him the most trust. It also implies an ostentatious gesture, and some have interpreted this as Judas kissing Jesus repeatedly. Such a kiss is still used in some cultures as a greeting, even among men. Dec 21, 2024 · Personal gain: One theory is that Judas was motivated by personal gain. It makes no sense to me that Judas, knowing that Jesus was the son of God, would betray him. I could kiss you right now. Another is that he just wasn't on the same frequency as Jesus Christ. The authorities knew about Jesus but the gospel writers highlighted Judas as the one who sought them out to make an arrest. I've always thought this explanation makes Judas seem somewhat reasonable. He received 30 pieces of silver, a significant amount of money, for his betrayal. But if that's the case, then why exactly did Jesus ask Judas to hand him over to the Pharisees in the gospel of Judas? For what purpose? Judas served a purpose in God’s plan of redemption for humanity. Then said Jesus unto him, That thou doest, do quickly. 35 subscribers in the okbuddychristianity community. That may have influenced the Like many, you confuse Gods foreknowledge with causation. Its one of the mysteries of the faith but Jesus obviously had knowledge of it. Jesus even tells him not to waste time and to get it done. The non-canon Gospel of Judas suggests that Jesus may have chosen Judas to betray him because Judas loved him the most, fulfilling some aspects of Old Testament sacrificial law. However, more to the point, he was already corrupt in his heart before he betrayed Jesus, so what makes sense to us wasn't what made sense to him at the time. Probably why Jesus notes how twisted the gesture is, betraying someone by an indication of love and affection. Jesus: funny you should say that, I need a favour. The gospels tell us that Judas betrayed Jesus for money and after the betrayal ceased to be one of the twelve. If God already knew Judas Iscariot would betray Jesus, then Judas never had a chance. ‭‭Luke 22:22 KJV‬‬ [22] And truly the Son of man goeth, as it was determined: but woe unto that man by whom he is betrayed! I get that, but it's about the basics of the action, not just how we do it. ” Why don't the people who actually put Jesus on the cross get the same flak Judas does? The people who were involved in his crucifixion aren't even named in the Bible. Nobody forced him to do it. Judas did what he thought was right, even though Satan and human emotions convinced him that was he was doing was right. Jesus knew that he was greedy, that he loved money more than the Lord, and that's why he chose Judas. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla I also include his response to another specific aspect related to the story of Judas. Both followed Jesus, both were trusted disciples (for the most part), both had the same teacher, both saw the same miracles, both betrayed Jesus. Joseph was one of the 12 sons of Jacob. We exist to provide a safe haven for all followers of Jesus Christ to discuss God, Jesus, the Bible, and information relative to our beliefs, and to provide non-believers a place to ask questions about Christianity as explained in the scriptures, without fear of mockery or debasement. Judas corrupted himself. As the OP rightly noted, in this pericope John clearly states that Jesus gave the bread to Judas (13:26), which is an act Jesus shares only with Judas, and then, moments later, Judas goes to betray Jesus. Can I prove it? No, who can? We are not there in the realm of the dead. Judas: I’ll do anything. Join us to learn more about what makes The Holy Bible so great, ask questions about The Bible, and be part of a community of Bible lovers like us! The text would say Satan entered Judas coupled with the fact that Jesus already called him a devil way before this happened, and despite the two different accounts of Judas‘s death either by hanging or throwing himself onto the ground it is still considered a suicide and a destruction of the temple - we both agreed that Judas is indeed in Hell. Before Judas went to the chief priests to betray Jesus, there was a disagreement about wasting perfume. Why did the Jews need Judas to betray jesus? They knew where he was and who he was. The one thing we DO know is that Judas didn't have to betray Jesus Christ. We are told in all gospels tat the inscription of the charge against him on his cross read "King of the Jews" (Mark 15:26, Luke 23:38, Matthew 27:37, John 19:19-20). 5K subscribers in the DemocraticUnderground community. Posted by u/ThatOneBlackGuy123 - 1 vote and 9 comments 5 subscribers in the BibleChristian community. For 20 pieces of silver. Through the Gospels it's implied that Judas was destined to betray Jesus, but the gospels are written after it happened. It gradually dawned on Judas, to his horror, that Jesus wasn't going to save himself. What conversation did they have? How did Jesus show his love for Judas then? One can only wonder. Judas was as necessary as Jesus. Jesus had nothing to do with that choice. He wanted Jesus to engage in what he was doing. Discord between Jesus and Judas: Some scholars believe that Jesus and Judas had a falling out, and Judas became disillusioned with Jesus’ teachings and the direction of the group. 1. He was sold into slavery by Judah. This is what Judas betrayed. Sometimes I wonder if Jesus ordered him to. All of it free will. Jesus, despite Judas betrayal is victorious. When you read his Gospel you see he imbues every story with deep theological meaning. Jesus knew Judas' heart when he picked him. Judas was not necessary for this. We, like Judas, betray Him and turn away from Him to get temporary pleasure from sin, even though we know its stupid. Scripture also clearly states that Satan entered into Judas when he saw his greed, and offered him the chance to betray Jesus for 30 lousy pieces of silver. That is presumably part of why he committed suicide afterward. He could have resisted the devil and prayed for help. Democratic Underground is an online community where politically liberal people can do their… 761K subscribers in the AskOuija community. He SAW him do that. I read an article awhile back where it said Judas never thought Jesus would be crucified. Today's value is $200. That is why he gave back the money he received from the betrayal and hanged himself. The son saw it happen just as his father said it would. In religious art, he is usually depicted kissing Christ on or near the lips. So what Judas did in itself was supposed to happen by someone. Just quieter. Was it for money like the Christians like to say it was? I doubt that. Judas had a unique opportunity. David, after all was betrayed by Ahithophel, who likewise hung himself. That got me thinking about why he would do this. 4 He said, “I have sinned by betraying innocent[b] blood. One thing is he was greedy, but that doesn't explain why he went to the rulers in the first place. Part of the author's argument was that the word usually translated betrayed (paradidómi) is better translated as "handed over," and that the conversation at the accounts of the Last Supper resemble the execution of a prearranged plan more than a secret betrayal. The other reason is that the central focus of the story (perhaps I should have left in the 200 word summary) was how a seemingly insignificant event that occurs during the EU4 timeframe, i. Jesus victory is all the more powerful because he overcame the betrayal. Judas did what he did, then went and killed himself. Do I personally (in spite of tradition) think Judas has a glimmer of hope? Yes, I do. 29: "Some thought that, because Judas had the common purse, Jesus was telling him, 'Buy what we need for the festival'; or, that he should give something to the poor. Some in my camp would argue that God foreknew Judas would betray Him, but ultimately its still Judas' choice. I believe every Jewish man in 1st Century Judea had a beard and probably the same haircut, so it makes sense that one who was close to Him needed to identify Him. That’s why they both knew at the last The betrayal of Jesus by Judas, was written first in the Old Testament. He fulfilled The Subreddit is dedicated to the understanding, discussion of, and loving of The Bible in all its greatness and everything it has to offer. Either way, Judas was from the south, the land dominated by the Israelite tribes who returned from Assyria 75 years earlier, and most likely descended from Edomite conver He makes the case that the canonical gospels writers used Judas as a figure of 'betrayal'. my subreddits. Like Barabbas, Judas was a zealot. But none of the apostles, Peter, Judas, James, Matthew or any of the others would have understood Jesus to be divine in any sense during Jesus' life. Iscariot means Man from Karioth; it was either an Edomite town in the far south, or a Moabite town across the Jordan River. As far as I know, (correct me if I'm wrong) no where in the gnostic gospels or even the four gospels in the canonical Bible say that Jesus came to die for our sins. forced anyone against their will to act as they did. We never know the lengths of God's mercy. He was a fake; not sure if the bible specifies whether or not he was always like this however. There are children of God and there are children of the devil. People can be (and often are) influenced or tempted by evil. He knew Judas never really believed and he knew Judas would betray him. There is only one universe and one timeline. Jesus foreknew that it would happen, but he didnt make it happen. Salvation comes through the death and resurrection of Christ--not through the betrayal and death and resurrection of Christ. Judas COULD have made other choices, but Jesus already knew what he WOULD choose. Why did Judas have to betray Jesus? I mean couldn't it of been anyone to just point him out and say hey! that's the guy! I would think a lot of people would be able to recognize him? I'm not challenging, just trying to understand it better. Despite Jesus’s knowledge of the impending betrayal, he did not attempt to stop Judas or retaliate In fact, no one needed to betray Jesus. By speaking down to Jesus like this Judas proclaimed himself to be higher. ocpjt mtwk gxwlg vlna utp wmxdcgxn kuciln dwniw pxxn nzpfcs xtuwlg yfjcvv ifanrt kbwp gja